The History of the Standard Oil Company

Glossary

"

"A Modern War for Independence": Tarbell's chapter title for the independent producers' and refiners' renewed struggle, decades after the 1872 Oil War, to build pipelines and refining capacity free of Standard Oil's control — including the fight for the Seaboard Pipe-Line to reach East Coast markets without Standard's cooperation, framed by Tarbell as a direct echo of the earlier generation's resistance.; Related: Cutting to Kill, The Oil War of 1872
"Cutting to Kill": Tarbell's name, drawn from her chapter title, for Standard Oil's practice of temporarily slashing prices below cost in specific local markets to drive independent competitors out of business, then raising prices again once the rival was eliminated — a tactic distinct from ordinary price competition because it was deliberately localized and reversible, aimed at destroying rather than simply outcompeting rivals.; Related: The War on the Rebate, A Modern War for Independence
"The Price of Oil": Tarbell's chapter examining Standard Oil's pricing practices in aggregate — comparing crude and refined oil prices across markets and time periods to assess whether the company's control actually delivered the price stability and consumer benefit its defenders claimed, part of her broader effort to weigh the company's economic record with the same documentary rigor she applied to its methods.; Related: The Legitimate Greatness of the Standard Oil Company, Cutting to Kill

E

Edwin L. "Colonel" Drake: The small stockholder in the Seneca Oil Company, forty years old and unqualified by any prior experience beyond "a dash of pioneer blood and a great persistency," who was sent to Titusville in 1858 to drill for oil and succeeded in August 1859 — an achievement popularly credited as "discovering oil," though the underlying idea of drilling (rather than skimming surface springs) likely built on existing knowledge of oil found while drilling for salt water.; Related: The Drake Well, Titusville, Pennsylvania

F

Frank S. Monnett: The Ohio Attorney General who, acting on George Rice's evidence, pursued contempt proceedings against the Standard Oil Company of Ohio for evading the 1892 dissolution order and filed anti-trust petitions against four constituent Standard companies (including the Ohio Oil Company and the Buckeye Pipe Line) for operating as a single, illegally undisclosed combination — personally examining a famously unflappable Rockefeller under oath before his investigation was cut short by his successor after Monnett's term expired in 1900.; Related: George Rice, The Breaking Up of the Trust, John D. Rockefeller

G

George H. Bissell: The Dartmouth-educated founder of the Pennsylvania Rock-Oil Company (later the Seneca Oil Company), who first grasped rock-oil's commercial potential after seeing a bottle of it in his old college's laboratory, commissioned Professor Silliman's analysis proving its value as an illuminant, and — according to Oil Regions legend — got the idea to drill for it after noticing an artesian-well illustration on a bottle of Kier's Petroleum in a New York drugstore window.; Related: The Drake Well, Samuel M. Kier, Professor Silliman
George Rice: The persistent Standard Oil Trust certificate holder whose refusal to quietly accept the trust's post-1892 "liquidation" — he suspected, correctly, that dissolution was a sham designed to consolidate the trustees' effective control while appearing to comply with the Ohio court's order — led him to pursue his suspicions through legal counsel, ultimately helping trigger Attorney General Frank Monnett's investigation into the trust's true structure.; Related: The Breaking Up of the Trust, Frank S. Monnett, John D. Rockefeller

H

Henry M. Flagler: The partner Rockefeller brought into his refining businesses to open a New York sales office, and whose later testimony about a twenty-five-cent-per-barrel rebate from the Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railroad — paid to Standard Oil in direct violation of a public agreement guaranteeing all shippers equal rates — became key documentary evidence in Tarbell's case against Standard Oil's transportation advantages.; Related: John D. Rockefeller, Rebates and Drawbacks

I

Ida M. Tarbell: The journalist and author of this history, serialized in McClure's Magazine beginning in 1902 and published as a book in 1904. Tarbell grew up in the Titusville oil fields she chronicles, the daughter of a small independent oil producer whose business was affected by Standard Oil's rise, and built her case from documents, court records, and testimony rather than personal grievance — establishing the template for American investigative ("muckraking") journalism.; Related: Titusville, Pennsylvania, McClure's Magazine, The South Improvement Company

J

John D. Archbold: A young Titusville refiner who, along with his partners, refused to join the South Improvement Company, publicly denounced it as "iniquitous" at the first Titusville mass meeting, and helped lead the fight to break it up in 1872 — only to later become vice-president of the very Standard Oil Company that absorbed much of the industry the South Improvement Company had tried to seize by force, an irony Tarbell notes without extended comment.; Related: The South Improvement Company, The Oil War of 1872
John D. Rockefeller: The founder and dominant figure of Standard Oil, whom Tarbell builds through documented conduct rather than direct personal attack — tracing him from a frugal Cleveland bookkeeper who prized "driving a good bargain," through his 1862 backing of Samuel Andrews's refinery, to his 1870 consolidation of his companies into the Standard Oil Company, and finally to his composed, evasive courtroom testimony under Ohio Attorney General Monnett's investigation decades later.; Related: The Standard Oil Company, Samuel Andrews, The South Improvement Company

M

McClure's Magazine: The muckraking periodical that serialized Tarbell's investigation beginning in 1902, ahead of its 1904 book publication — part of a wave of turn-of-the-century investigative journalism (alongside figures like Lincoln Steffens) that used sustained, documented reporting to expose corporate and political corruption, helping build the public and legal momentum behind the antitrust movement.; Related: Ida M. Tarbell

P

Peter H. Watson: The president of the South Improvement Company (and later of the Erie Railroad) who tried to defend the scheme to angry Oil Regions producers by letter, insisting the rebate arrangement would "enhance the price of oil at the wells" — an appeal the producers rejected outright, refusing even to negotiate with him directly, which Tarbell presents as evidence of how completely the scheme's secrecy had poisoned trust in its organizers.; Related: The South Improvement Company, The Oil War of 1872
Pithole: The Oil Creek boomtown that sprang up almost overnight after a well struck 250 barrels a day in January 1865 — reaching 6,000 inhabitants within six weeks, fifty hotels within a year, and a post office ranked third-busiest in the state — before its oil played out and it collapsed just as fast, a boom-and-bust story Tarbell uses to capture the Oil Regions' frontier volatility.; Related: Titusville, Pennsylvania, The Empire Transportation Company
Professor Silliman: The Yale chemist whose 1855 paid analysis of rock-oil, commissioned by George Bissell, established that petroleum could yield illuminating oil, gas, paraffine, and lubricating oil through simple, inexpensive processing — a report whose publication gave the fledgling Pennsylvania Rock-Oil Company the scientific credibility to pursue drilling.; Related: George H. Bissell, The Drake Well

R

Rebates and Drawbacks: The railroad pricing mechanisms Tarbell identifies as the true engine of Standard Oil's dominance: a rebate secretly returned part of the posted freight rate to a favored shipper, while a drawback went further, paying that shipper a fee on every barrel a competitor shipped — meaning Standard Oil could profit even from its rivals' business. Documented instances include Flagler's twenty-five-cent-per-barrel rebate from the Lake Shore road and the South Improvement Company's blanket drawback scheme.; Related: The South Improvement Company, The War on the Rebate

S

Samuel Andrews: The English mechanical genius whose refining processes, backed by $4,000 from Clark and Rockefeller in 1862, formed the technical foundation of what became Standard Oil — steadily improving the quality and yield of refined oil while Rockefeller handled the buying, selling, and relentless cost-cutting that Tarbell credits as much as Andrews's chemistry for the firm's early growth.; Related: John D. Rockefeller, The Standard Oil Company
Samuel M. Kier: The Pittsburgh salt-well operator who, by 1850, had built a substantial business bottling and selling the petroleum that came up as a nuisance byproduct of his salt wells as "Kier's Petroleum, or Rock-Oil," a patent-medicine cure-all — and who, on a Philadelphia chemist's advice, distilled it and discovered its promise as a lubricant and illuminant, foreshadowing the industry Drake's well would create.; Related: The Drake Well, George H. Bissell
Standard Oil and Politics: Tarbell's examination of the company's influence over state and federal legislatures and courts — placing sympathetic officials, financing friendly candidates, and shaping legislation such as pipeline and taxation bills — which she presents as a natural extension of Standard Oil's economic dominance into the political machinery meant to check corporate power in the first place.; Related: The Breaking Up of the Trust, George Rice

T

The Breaking Up of the Trust: The legal saga following Ohio's 1892 court order dissolving the Standard Oil Trust — a dissolution Tarbell shows to have been largely cosmetic, as trust certificates were quietly converted into shares of the same constituent companies without meaningfully separating their operations, eventually prompting Ohio's contempt and anti-trust proceedings and driving Standard Oil to seek refuge under New Jersey's newly liberalized corporation law.; Related: The Trust, The New Jersey Holding Company, Frank S. Monnett
The Buffalo Case: A documented legal proceeding Tarbell examines in detail as a case study of Standard Oil's methods against a specific independent competitor in Buffalo, New York — used, alongside similar episodes, to demonstrate the company's pattern of combining transportation pressure, predatory pricing, and legal maneuvering to eliminate rivals in a single regional market.; Related: Cutting to Kill, The War on the Rebate
The Drake Well: The first artesian well drilled specifically for petroleum, struck near Titusville, Pennsylvania in late August 1859 by Edwin L. "Colonel" Drake — a former clerk and railway conductor with no relevant experience, sent by the Seneca Oil Company (formerly the Pennsylvania Rock-Oil Company) to find oil after Professor Silliman's chemical analysis proved its commercial value. Mocked as "Drake's Folly" until it produced twenty-five barrels a day, it triggered the transformation of a wilderness into the booming Oil Regions within months.; Related: Edwin L. Drake, Titusville, Pennsylvania, George H. Bissell
The Empire Transportation Company: The pipeline and freight-coordination company organized in 1865 under Colonel Joseph D. Potts to build east-west oil traffic over the Philadelphia and Erie Railroad, which pioneered key industry practices — running solid oil trains, issuing "run tickets" and later tradeable oil certificates to producers, and inventing wastage and fire-insurance assessments — that remain standard practice, according to Tarbell, in the oil trade of her own day.; Related: The Van Syckel Pipe-Line, Pithole
The Legitimate Greatness of the Standard Oil Company: Tarbell's title for her penultimate chapter, in which she deliberately credits Standard Oil's genuine achievements — organizational efficiency, technical innovation, economies of scale — distinguishing them from the illegitimate methods (rebates, predatory pricing, political capture) she spends the rest of the book documenting, a structural choice that underscores her investigative method: building a case from evidence rather than blanket condemnation.; Related: Ida M. Tarbell, The Price of Oil
The New Jersey Holding Company: The legal refuge Standard Oil found once Ohio's courts threatened its constituent companies' charters: New Jersey's amended corporation law, which permitted one company to hold stock in others far more permissively than most states allowed, letting Standard Oil reorganize as a holding company — Standard Oil of New Jersey — that preserved centralized control without the trust structure's now-legally-vulnerable form.; Related: The Breaking Up of the Trust, The Trust
The Oil War of 1872: The Oil Regions' furious, largely successful uprising against the South Improvement Company once its rate scheme leaked out in February 1872 — a 3,000-strong mass meeting at Titusville, the formation of the Petroleum Producers' Union, a total boycott ("blacklist") of South Improvement refiners, and petitions to the Pennsylvania Legislature and Congress — which forced the railroads to publicly cancel the South Improvement contracts within weeks, even though secret rebates to Standard Oil resumed almost immediately afterward.; Related: The South Improvement Company, John D. Archbold
The South Improvement Company: The secret 1872 scheme among a small group of refiners, including Standard Oil, and the three major oil-carrying railroads to fix inflated freight rates for outsiders while granting themselves steep rebates — and, in its most inflammatory provision, a "drawback" payment on every barrel a competitor shipped, even though the scheme company handled none of that oil itself. Tarbell treats its exposure and defeat by the Oil Regions' Petroleum Producers' Union as the pivotal, if ultimately temporary, check on Standard Oil's rise, since Rockefeller's company simply pursued the same ends by other means afterward.; Related: Rebates and Drawbacks, The Oil War of 1872, Peter H. Watson
The Standard Oil Company: The firm John D. Rockefeller formed in June 1870, consolidating his various Cleveland refining interests into a single company capitalized at $1,000,000, with Rockefeller, Flagler, Andrews, Stephen V. Harkness, and William Rockefeller as the interested parties — the entity whose subsequent growth through railroad rebates, predatory competition, and eventually the 1882 trust structure is the book's central subject.; Related: John D. Rockefeller, The South Improvement Company, The Trust
The Trust: The 1882 Standard Oil Trust — the legal device by which formally separate Standard companies were placed under the unified control of a small board of trustees holding stock in trust for shareholders, letting Rockefeller coordinate an entire industry's pricing and output while the constituent firms remained nominally independent competitors on paper. Ohio courts ordered it dissolved in 1892, but Tarbell documents how the "liquidation" left effective control almost entirely unchanged.; Related: The Standard Oil Company, The Breaking Up of the Trust, The New Jersey Holding Company
The Van Syckel Pipe-Line: The first commercially successful oil pipeline, built in 1865 by Samuel Van Syckel to move oil from Pithole to the railroad after teamsters' extortionate hauling rates ate into his profits — an innovation Tarbell calls, after the Drake well, "the most important event in the history of the Oil Regions," since it broke the teamsters' chokehold on transportation (some of whom retaliated by cutting the buried pipe and burning storage tanks) and made large-scale, low-cost oil gathering possible.; Related: Pithole, The Empire Transportation Company
The War on the Rebate: The sustained public and legal campaign — including state investigations, the federal Hepburn Committee hearings, and eventually the Interstate Commerce Act's anti-discrimination provisions — to expose and outlaw the secret railroad rebates that Tarbell identifies as Standard Oil's foundational advantage, a fight that proved only partially successful since rebates persisted, in modified and better-hidden forms, well into the years Tarbell was writing.; Related: Rebates and Drawbacks, The Buffalo Case
Titusville, Pennsylvania: The Oil Creek lumbermen's hamlet, fourteen miles from the Allegheny River, where Drake's 1859 well launched the American oil industry — transforming the surrounding Northwestern Pennsylvania region within twelve years from wilderness into a booming, railroad-connected trade center. Tarbell grew up here among the independent oil producers whose world Standard Oil's rise would upend.; Related: The Drake Well, Pithole, Ida M. Tarbell